Penn ⇄ Fire Island Pines · Early Fall 2026 | Prologue Provisioners

Stops at Cherry Grove

Starts Service begins this date

Monday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

5:35A

No convenient train

6:10A

Last trip Sept. 21

4:28A

viaBabylon·Sayville6:01A·wait59m·ferry7:00A·3h 07

7:35A

8:32A

viaJamaica·Sayville9:59A·wait21m·ferry10:20A·2h 08

10:40A

11:22A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:54P·wait26m·ferry1:20P·2h 18

1:40P

1:22P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:54P·wait36m·ferry3:30P·2h 28

3:50P

3:17P

viaBabylon·Sayville4:49P·wait31m·ferry5:20P·2h 23

5:40P

5:16P

viaBabylon·Sayville7:01P·wait19m·ferry7:20P·2h 39

7:55P

Sept. 14 only

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

6:20A

Sayville7:32A·viaJamaica·wait37m·2h 33

8:53A

Last trip Sept. 21

7:25A

Sayville8:36A·viaBabylon·wait36m·2h 36

10:01A

10:50A

Sayville11:47A·viaBabylon·wait37m·2h 27

1:17P

1:50P

Sayville2:42P·viaBabylon·wait32m·2h 19

4:09P

4:00P

Sayville4:51P·viaJamaica·wait31m·2h 13

6:13P

5:50P

Sayville6:38P·viaBabylon·wait28m·2h 15

8:05P

8:05P

Sayville9:45P·viaJamaica·wait65m·3h 10

11:15P

Sept. 14 only

Tuesday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

4:28A

viaBabylon·Sayville6:01A·wait59m·ferry7:00A·3h 07

7:35A

8:32A

viaJamaica·Sayville9:59A·wait21m·ferry10:20A·2h 08

10:40A

11:22A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:54P·wait26m·ferry1:20P·2h 18

1:40P

1:22P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:54P·wait36m·ferry3:30P·2h 28

3:50P

3:17P

viaBabylon·Sayville4:49P·wait31m·ferry5:20P·2h 23

5:40P

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

7:25A

Sayville8:36A·viaBabylon·wait36m·2h 36

10:01A

10:50A

Sayville11:47A·viaBabylon·wait37m·2h 27

1:17P

1:50P

Sayville2:42P·viaBabylon·wait32m·2h 19

4:09P

4:00P

Sayville4:51P·viaJamaica·wait31m·2h 13

6:13P

5:50P

Sayville6:38P·viaBabylon·wait28m·2h 15

8:05P

Wednesday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

4:28A

viaBabylon·Sayville6:01A·wait59m·ferry7:00A·3h 07

7:35A

8:32A

viaJamaica·Sayville9:59A·wait21m·ferry10:20A·2h 08

10:40A

11:22A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:54P·wait26m·ferry1:20P·2h 18

1:40P

1:22P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:54P·wait36m·ferry3:30P·2h 28

3:50P

3:17P

viaBabylon·Sayville4:49P·wait31m·ferry5:20P·2h 23

5:40P

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

7:25A

Sayville8:36A·viaBabylon·wait36m·2h 36

10:01A

10:50A

Sayville11:47A·viaBabylon·wait37m·2h 27

1:17P

1:50P

Sayville2:42P·viaBabylon·wait32m·2h 19

4:09P

4:00P

Sayville4:51P·viaJamaica·wait31m·2h 13

6:13P

5:50P

Sayville6:38P·viaBabylon·wait28m·2h 15

8:05P

Thursday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

4:28A

viaBabylon·Sayville6:01A·wait59m·ferry7:00A·3h 07

7:35A

7:20A

viaBabylon·Sayville8:56A·wait24m·ferry9:20A·2h 20

9:40A

9:19A

viaBabylon·Sayville10:55A·wait25m·ferry11:20A·2h 21

11:40A

11:22A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:54P·wait26m·ferry1:20P·2h 18

1:40P

1:22P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:54P·wait36m·ferry3:30P·2h 28

3:50P

3:17P

viaBabylon·Sayville4:49P·wait31m·ferry5:20P·2h 23

5:40P

5:16P

viaBabylon·Sayville7:01P·wait29m·ferry7:30P·2h 34

7:50P

6:28P

viadirect·Sayville7:53P·wait37m·ferry8:30P·2h 22

8:50P

Last trip Sept. 24

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

7:25A

Sayville8:36A·viaBabylon·wait36m·2h 36

10:01A

9:50A

Sayville10:47A·viaBabylon·wait37m·2h 27

12:17P

11:50A

Sayville1:22P·viaJamaica·wait72m·3h 01

2:51P

1:50P

Sayville2:42P·viaBabylon·wait32m·2h 19

4:09P

4:00P

Sayville4:51P·viaJamaica·wait31m·2h 13

6:13P

5:50P

Sayville6:38P·viaBabylon·wait28m·2h 15

8:05P

8:00P

Sayville9:45P·viaJamaica·wait85m·3h 15

11:15P

9:00P

Sayville9:45P·viaJamaica·wait25m·2h 15

11:15P

Last trip Sept. 24

Friday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

4:28A

viaBabylon·Sayville6:01A·wait59m·ferry7:00A·3h 07

7:35A

7:20A

viaBabylon·Sayville8:56A·wait24m·ferry9:20A·2h 20

9:40A

9:19A

viaBabylon·Sayville10:55A·wait25m·ferry11:20A·2h 21

11:40A

11:22A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:54P·wait26m·ferry1:20P·2h 18

1:40P

1:22P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:54P·wait36m·ferry3:30P·2h 28

3:50P

3:17P

viaBabylon·Sayville4:49P·wait31m·ferry5:20P·2h 23

5:40P

5:16P

viaBabylon·Sayville7:01P·wait19m·ferry7:20P·2h 24

7:40P

6:28P

viadirect·Sayville7:53P·wait27m·ferry8:20P·2h 27

8:55P

Last trip Sept. 25

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

7:25A

Sayville8:36A·viaBabylon·wait36m·2h 36

10:01A

9:50A

Sayville10:47A·viaBabylon·wait37m·2h 27

12:17P

11:50A

Sayville1:22P·viaJamaica·wait72m·3h 01

2:51P

1:50P

Sayville2:42P·viaBabylon·wait32m·2h 19

4:09P

4:00P

Sayville4:51P·viaJamaica·wait31m·2h 13

6:13P

5:50P

Sayville6:38P·viaBabylon·wait28m·2h 15

8:05P

7:50P

Sayville9:45P·viaJamaica·wait95m·3h 25

11:15P

9:05P

Sayville10:39P·viaBabylon·wait59m·3h 08

12:13A

Last trip Sept. 25

Saturday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

8:00A

No convenient train

8:35A

7:47A

viaJamaica·Sayville9:09A·wait21m·ferry9:30A·2h 03

9:50A

8:42A

viaJamaica·Sayville10:15A·wait15m·ferry10:30A·2h 08

10:50A

9:16A

viaJamaica·Sayville10:46A·wait44m·ferry11:30A·2h 34

11:50A

11:21A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:57P·wait33m·ferry1:30P·2h 29

1:50P

1:21P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:57P·wait33m·ferry3:30P·2h 29

3:50P

2:14P

viaJamaica·Sayville3:44P·wait46m·ferry4:30P·2h 36

4:50P

4:21P

viaBabylon·Sayville5:58P·wait32m·ferry6:30P·2h 29

6:50P

5:14P

viaJamaica·Sayville6:45P·wait45m·ferry7:30P·2h 36

7:50P

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

8:25A

Sayville10:45A·viaBabylon·wait105m·3h 54

12:19P

10:00A

Sayville10:45A·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 19

12:19P

11:00A

Sayville11:45A·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 17

1:17P

12:00N

Sayville12:46P·viaBabylon·wait26m·2h 17

2:17P

2:00P

Sayville2:45P·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 17

4:17P

4:00P

Sayville4:45P·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 17

6:17P

5:00P

Sayville5:41P·viaJamaica·wait21m·2h 11

7:11P

7:00P

Sayville7:45P·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 19

9:19P

8:00P

Sayville8:38P·viaJamaica·wait18m·2h 02

10:02P

Sunday

To the Pines

LeavePennArriveF.I. Pines

8:00A

No convenient train

8:35A

Last trip Sept. 13

7:47A

viaJamaica·Sayville9:09A·wait21m·ferry9:30A·2h 03

9:50A

9:16A

viaJamaica·Sayville10:46A·wait44m·ferry11:30A·2h 34

11:50A

11:21A

viaBabylon·Sayville12:57P·wait33m·ferry1:30P·2h 29

1:50P

1:21P

viaBabylon·Sayville2:57P·wait33m·ferry3:30P·2h 29

3:50P

2:14P

viaJamaica·Sayville3:44P·wait46m·ferry4:30P·2h 36

4:50P

3:21P

viaBabylon·Sayville4:58P·wait32m·ferry5:30P·2h 29

5:50P

4:21P

viaBabylon·Sayville5:58P·wait32m·ferry6:30P·2h 29

6:50P

5:14P

viaJamaica·Sayville6:45P·wait45m·ferry7:30P·2h 36

7:50P

To the City

LeaveF.I. PinesArrivePenn

8:25A

Sayville10:45A·viaBabylon·wait105m·3h 54

12:19P

Last trip Sept. 13

10:00A

Sayville10:45A·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 19

12:19P

12:00N

Sayville12:46P·viaBabylon·wait26m·2h 17

2:17P

2:00P

Sayville2:45P·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 17

4:17P

4:00P

Sayville4:45P·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 17

6:17P

5:00P

Sayville5:41P·viaJamaica·wait21m·2h 11

7:11P

6:00P

Sayville6:38P·viaJamaica·wait18m·2h 02

8:02P

7:00P

Sayville7:45P·viaBabylon·wait25m·2h 19

9:19P

8:00P

Sayville8:38P·viaJamaica·wait18m·2h 02

10:02P